A couple weeks ago, I experienced an epic night of bowling that spanned two bowling alleys, five games, several pitchers of beer and one game of pool. (That night, I managed to bowl not quite as suckily as I normally do, and my friend Greg compels me to share that he bowled a 163 in the fourth game of the night, after many drinks. You happy now, Greg?)
As the excursion began and ended at Brooklyn Bowl, it was also a night that included not one but TWO meals of Blue Ribbon fried chicken and mac and cheese. (I told you it was an epic night.) Now, about the Blue Ribbon fried chicken, there isn't much I can say that hasn't already been said. Namely: It's fantastic. But the mac and cheese was a revelation. Being lactose intolerant, I don't tend to eat a lot of mac and cheese, which means that my saying "best mac and cheese I've ever had" may not mean all that much. But still. It was creamy, divine ... the best mac and cheese I've ever had.
Since I've been trying to get back on the Tell Me What to Cook train, I was thusly inspired to tackle Abby's suggestion of mac and cheese. First I had to do some research, so off the Internets I went. And the recipe that people seemed to praise over and over and over again was Martha Stewart's for Perfect Macaroni and Cheese, otherwise known as Crack and Cheese. How could I resist?
As a mac and cheese neophyte, I do not trust myself to judge the dish properly. So I invited over some help: Nomi, Lydia, Annah and McGregor, along with their two-year-old son Adger. (Adger, it must be noted, was not much of a fan of the main course, though he did like the Brillat-Savarin cheese and salami I set out beforehand.)
While waiting for my Fresh Direct order, I decided to make Mark Bittman's Maple Pear Upside-Down Cake. But upon re-reading the recipe, I realized: I don't have a hand mixer. I never bake, and I know I had a hand mixer once -- I still have the metal beater things that attach to one -- but I guess it must've broken at some point and I never replaced it. After hitting the grocery store, I headed to the local discount store that carries everything from Advil to coffeemakers to needles and thread. But they were out of hand mixers, and sent me to the vacuum cleaner store next door. All they had was immersion blenders.
I bought one and brought it home, figuring, better than nothing, right? But no ... one cannot mix sugar and butter together "until light and fluffy" with an immersion blender. I puzzled and despaired, an acrid smell filling the air as I grimly forced the poor tool to tackle a task for which it was entirely unsuited. And then I figured, people were making cakes well before electricity came along, right? If they could do it, I can do it. I flung away the immersion blender and continued by hand. And it came out all right in the end.
And now, to the mac and cheese. The grating of the cheese -- cheddar and Gruyere -- took a prodigiously long time on my puny cheapo grater. It was a LOT of cheese. Grating cheese, I have now discovered, is not my favorite task in the world. I cut myself, but fortunately did not bleed onto any of the cheese. Note to self: Buy a better grater.
Slices of white bread got tossed with melted butter, creating some mighty hefty breadcrumbs.
And now, the bechamel. I had never made bechamel before -- roux, yes, but bechamel, no. It thickens up after you stir it for a really (really) long time. Like magic!
It immediately melted in the most lovely way. Again, magic! Or, you know, science. And then came the macaroni, which for once I actually cooked early enough be able to add at the proper time. (Usually I get to this point in the recipe, go "oh shit," set the pot of water on, and have to halt everything while I wait for it to boil.)
I had wanted to add pancetta to the recipe, because I like a little meat in my mac and cheese. But then I got nervous at all the comments in the blog posts saying they'd made the recipe exactly as is, and it was perfect. Who am I to mess with perfection? Or with Martha, for that matter? (After all, perfection and Martha are just about the same thing.) Therefore, I compromised and made one portion with pancetta, and the rest without.
More cheese went on top, plus the bread crumbs.
Half an hour in a 375-degree oven, and aaaaah. Well, first, we started with a delicious fennel and onion soup that Nomi had come over and made, from the cookbook Love Soup. It was so good, it makes me want to go out and make a bunch of vegetarian soups. Yes, me! And then it was time for the main course.
I served with a simple green salad. Was going to steam some broccoli, but I ran out of time, and with so much food already I figured, why bother?
Verdict: yummy. The breadcrumbs really made it. And I preferred the version with the pancetta, because it balanced out the cheesiness; the plain version was super-cheesy (though if you're a big fan of super-cheesy, of course, that's your way to go).
It just so happened to be national Open That Bottle Night (which, as you recall, we celebrated grandly two years ago, though not on the official date). So Annah and McGregor brought a very nice bottle of Shiraz that they'd been saving for a couple years, and I opened a bottle of Sandeman port my parents had brought back from Portugal. Everything was eaten, and drunk, and enjoyed, and we toasted Abby for the original idea; and people had seconds of the mac and cheese (and thirds of the pear upside-down cake), which made me exceedingly happy; and I sent everyone home with leftovers. I had some of the mac and cheese for lunch today. If anything, it tasted even better.
All in all, the night was a very Good Thing. Thanks, Martha.